Yipes and then some across the board. I wish I could give you some sort of meaningful advice about law school and the path before you, but all I know about the law is from TV. (Therefore: If you stay in Boston, all the lawyers look and talk like characters on David E. Kelley TV shows from ten years ago.)

But...as much as I think you belong in NYC, if you are happy in Boston, stay in Boston. If you miss NYC, come back here. You have a lot to think about in terms of your career, so I would suggest not overthinking the rest. But that's just me (and as you might be able to guess, I tend towards inertia in my own life, so my experiences might not be the best guide.)